Variance Analysis

Understanding Variance Analysis in Cost Estimation and Control

Variance analysis is a crucial tool in cost estimation and control, helping project managers identify deviations from the planned budget and performance. It allows them to understand the reasons behind these deviations and take corrective action to optimize resource allocation and achieve project goals.

This article explores various variance analyses, explaining their significance in cost management.

Cost Variance Analysis

Cost variance measures the difference between the Budgeted Cost of Work Performed (BCWP) and the Actual Cost of Work Performed (ACWP).

BCWP: Represents the value of work completed as per the project schedule.
ACWP: Represents the actual cost incurred to complete the work.

Formula: Cost Variance (CV) = BCWP - ACWP

Positive CV: Indicates that the project is under budget, as the actual cost is less than the budgeted cost.
Negative CV: Indicates that the project is over budget, as the actual cost exceeds the budgeted cost.

Percentage Over/Under Analysis:

This analysis provides a percentage representation of the cost variance relative to the BCWP, highlighting the severity of the deviation.

Formula: % Over/Under = 100 x (ACWP - BCWP) / BCWP

Unit Variance Analysis

This analysis focuses on individual cost components and their respective variances. It helps pinpoint specific areas requiring attention for cost control. Key aspects include:

1. Labor Rate Variance:

Compares the actual labor rate paid to the budgeted labor rate.
Formula: Actual Labor Rate - Budgeted Labor Rate

2. Labor Hours/Units of Work Accomplished Variance:

Compares the actual labor hours worked to the budgeted labor hours for the completed work.
Formula: Actual Labor Hours - Budgeted Labor Hours

3. Material Rate Variance:

Compares the actual material cost per unit to the budgeted material cost per unit.
Formula: Actual Material Rate - Budgeted Material Rate

4. Material Usage Variance:

Compares the actual quantity of material used to the budgeted quantity for the completed work.
Formula: Actual Material Usage - Budgeted Material Usage

Schedule/Performance Analysis

Schedule/Performance variance measures the difference between the Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled (BCWS) and the BCWP.

BCWS: Represents the planned value of work to be completed by a specific point in time.
BCWP: Represents the actual value of work completed as per the project schedule.

Formula: Schedule/Performance Variance (SV) = BCWP - BCWS

Positive SV: Indicates that the project is ahead of schedule, as more work is completed than planned.
Negative SV: Indicates that the project is behind schedule, as less work is completed than planned.

Conclusion:

Variance analysis is essential for effective cost management and project control. By identifying and analyzing cost deviations, project managers can proactively address challenges, optimize resource allocation, and ensure project completion within budget and schedule. Regularly reviewing and evaluating variances helps improve decision-making, leading to successful project outcomes.

Test Your Knowledge

Quiz: Understanding Variance Analysis in Cost Estimation and Control

Instructions: Choose the best answer for each question.

1. Which of the following is NOT a component of Cost Variance Analysis?

a) Budgeted Cost of Work Performed (BCWP) b) Actual Cost of Work Performed (ACWP) c) Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled (BCWS) d) Cost Variance (CV)

Answer

c) Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled (BCWS)

2. A positive Cost Variance (CV) indicates that the project is:

a) Over budget b) Under budget c) On budget d) Behind schedule

Answer

b) Under budget

3. What does the formula "% Over/Under = 100 x (ACWP - BCWP) / BCWP" calculate?

a) Schedule/Performance Variance b) Percentage deviation from the budgeted cost c) Labor Rate Variance d) Material Usage Variance

Answer

b) Percentage deviation from the budgeted cost

4. Which variance analysis focuses on the difference between actual labor hours worked and budgeted labor hours?

a) Labor Rate Variance b) Labor Hours/Units of Work Accomplished Variance c) Material Rate Variance d) Material Usage Variance

Answer

b) Labor Hours/Units of Work Accomplished Variance

5. A negative Schedule/Performance Variance (SV) indicates that the project is:

a) Ahead of schedule b) Behind schedule c) Over budget d) Under budget

Answer

b) Behind schedule

Exercise: Analyzing Variance

Scenario: You are managing a project with a budgeted cost of $100,000. The project is currently 50% complete. The BCWP is $45,000 and the ACWP is $50,000.

Task:

Calculate the Cost Variance (CV).
Calculate the percentage over/under.
Interpret the results.

Exercice Correction

1. **Cost Variance (CV):** CV = BCWP - ACWP CV = $45,000 - $50,000 **CV = -$5,000** 2. **Percentage Over/Under:** % Over/Under = 100 x (ACWP - BCWP) / BCWP % Over/Under = 100 x ($50,000 - $45,000) / $45,000 **% Over/Under = 11.11%** 3. **Interpretation:** * **Negative CV:** The project is over budget by $5,000. * **11.11% over budget:** The project is currently 11.11% over the planned budget. This analysis indicates that the project is currently exceeding its budget. Project managers should investigate the reasons behind this variance and take corrective action to control costs and bring the project back on track.

Books

Project Management: A Systems Approach to Planning, Scheduling, and Controlling by Harold Kerzner: This comprehensive textbook covers various aspects of project management, including cost estimation and variance analysis.
Cost Management for Project Managers: Understanding Cost Concepts and Techniques by Jeffrey Pinto: This book provides practical insights into cost management techniques, including variance analysis, for project managers.
Cost Engineering: Principles and Practice by AACE International: This authoritative guide offers in-depth coverage of cost engineering principles and methods, including variance analysis.
The Project Manager's Guide to Earned Value Management by David Hill: This book focuses on earned value management (EVM), a widely used method for project performance tracking, which relies heavily on variance analysis.

Articles

"Variance Analysis: A Powerful Tool for Cost Control" by David P. Deering, Project Management Journal: This article provides a detailed explanation of variance analysis and its application in cost control.
"The Importance of Variance Analysis in Project Management" by Project Management Institute: This article discusses the significance of variance analysis for achieving project success.
"Understanding and Using Cost Variance Analysis" by Construction Management: This article focuses on the use of variance analysis in construction projects.

Online Resources

Project Management Institute (PMI): PMI offers a wealth of resources on project management, including articles, webinars, and certification programs related to cost management and variance analysis. (https://www.pmi.org/)
AACE International: This professional organization provides comprehensive information on cost engineering, including various resources on variance analysis. (https://www.aacei.org/)
The Earned Value Management Association (EVMA): EVMA provides resources and training on EVM, including the use of variance analysis for project performance tracking. (https://www.evma.org/)

Search Tips

Use specific keywords: When searching for information on variance analysis, use terms like "variance analysis," "cost variance," "schedule variance," "earned value management," and "cost estimation."
Refine your search: Specify the type of project or industry you are interested in, for example, "variance analysis in construction projects" or "variance analysis in software development."
Use quotation marks: If you need to find a specific phrase, enclose it in quotation marks. For example, "variance analysis for cost control."
Explore related terms: Research related terms to gain a broader understanding of the topic. For example, search for "cost control techniques," "project performance tracking," or "earned value management principles."

Techniques

Understanding Variance Analysis in Cost Estimation and Control

This expanded document delves deeper into variance analysis, broken down into separate chapters for clarity.

Chapter 1: Techniques of Variance Analysis

Variance analysis employs several techniques to dissect cost and schedule deviations. The core methodologies revolve around comparing planned values against actual results. Key techniques include:

Cost Variance Analysis: This fundamental technique compares the Budgeted Cost of Work Performed (BCWP) with the Actual Cost of Work Performed (ACWP). A positive variance indicates savings, while a negative variance signals cost overruns. The formula remains: CV = BCWP - ACWP. Further analysis can be performed by decomposing the variance into its contributing factors (e.g., labor, materials, overhead).
Percentage Over/Under Analysis: This builds upon cost variance by expressing the deviation as a percentage of the BCWP, providing a relative measure of the significance of the variance. The formula is: % Over/Under = 100 x (ACWP - BCWP) / BCWP. This percentage helps contextualize the absolute cost variance.
Unit Variance Analysis: This dives deeper into individual cost components, offering granular insights into the sources of variances. Specific unit variances include:
- Labor Rate Variance: Actual Labor Rate - Budgeted Labor Rate
- Labor Efficiency Variance (Hours/Units): (Actual Labor Hours - Budgeted Labor Hours) * Budgeted Labor Rate (Note: This is a more precise calculation than simply subtracting hours).
- Material Price Variance: (Actual Material Price - Budgeted Material Price) * Actual Quantity
- Material Usage Variance: (Actual Material Quantity - Budgeted Material Quantity) * Budgeted Material Price
- Overhead Variance: Analyzing variances in indirect costs (rent, utilities, etc.) often requires a more detailed allocation method.
Schedule/Performance Variance Analysis: This compares the Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled (BCWS) with the BCWP to assess schedule performance. SV = BCWP - BCWS. A positive SV means ahead of schedule, while a negative SV indicates being behind. This analysis, combined with cost variance, helps understand whether cost overruns are due to schedule delays or other inefficiencies.
Trend Analysis: Tracking variances over time to identify patterns and predict future performance. This is crucial for proactive intervention.

Chapter 2: Models for Variance Analysis

Several models facilitate variance analysis, depending on project complexity and data availability.

Earned Value Management (EVM): A comprehensive project management technique that integrates scope, schedule, and cost data to provide a holistic view of project performance. EVM utilizes BCWS, BCWP, and ACWP to calculate variances and performance indices (e.g., Schedule Performance Index (SPI), Cost Performance Index (CPI)).
Regression Analysis: Statistical techniques can model relationships between cost drivers and project outcomes, helping to identify key factors influencing variances and make predictions for future projects.
Statistical Process Control (SPC): Charts and tools monitor process variability and identify assignable causes for variances. This helps pinpoint systematic issues affecting costs.

Chapter 3: Software for Variance Analysis

Various software solutions streamline variance analysis.

Project Management Software (e.g., Microsoft Project, Primavera P6): These tools typically include built-in functionalities for tracking budgets, actual costs, and schedules, enabling automated variance calculations and reporting.
Spreadsheet Software (e.g., Microsoft Excel, Google Sheets): While less sophisticated than dedicated project management software, spreadsheets can be used to perform basic variance calculations and create visualizations.
Business Intelligence (BI) Tools (e.g., Tableau, Power BI): BI tools offer advanced data visualization and analysis capabilities, enabling complex variance analysis and reporting across multiple projects.
Dedicated Cost Management Software: Specialized software focuses specifically on cost control and variance analysis, providing detailed features and integration with other project management systems.

Chapter 4: Best Practices in Variance Analysis

Effective variance analysis requires a structured approach:

Establish a Baseline: A clearly defined and accurate baseline budget and schedule are crucial for meaningful variance analysis.
Regular Monitoring: Regularly monitor and analyze variances, ideally on a weekly or bi-weekly basis, to facilitate timely corrective actions.
Investigate Root Causes: Don't just identify variances; delve into the underlying reasons. Use techniques such as the "5 Whys" to uncover the root cause.
Develop Corrective Actions: Based on the root cause analysis, develop and implement appropriate corrective actions.
Document Everything: Maintain a comprehensive record of variances, root causes, and corrective actions for future reference and learning.
Communicate Effectively: Clearly communicate variances and corrective actions to relevant stakeholders.
Focus on Prevention: Learn from past variances to improve future project planning and execution.

Chapter 5: Case Studies of Variance Analysis

(This section would include specific examples of variance analysis in real-world projects. For instance, a case study might detail how a construction project used EVM to identify and resolve cost overruns caused by unforeseen site conditions or how a software development project used unit variance analysis to optimize labor costs.) Examples would need to be added based on available data. A hypothetical example follows:

Hypothetical Case Study: Software Development Project

A software development project had a budgeted cost of $100,000. After two months, the BCWP was $40,000, but the ACWP was $45,000. This resulted in a negative cost variance of $5,000. Further investigation (unit variance analysis) revealed that the labor efficiency variance was the primary contributor, indicating that developers were taking longer to complete tasks than anticipated. The project manager adjusted the schedule, provided additional training to the developers, and implemented more rigorous project tracking, resulting in improved performance and reduced cost overruns in subsequent months.

This structured approach, combining techniques, models, software, best practices, and real-world examples, enhances the understanding and application of variance analysis in project management.

Similar Terms

Emergency Response Planning