Bottom Up Cost Estimating

Diving Deep: Bottom-Up Cost Estimating in Oil & Gas

In the complex world of oil and gas projects, accurate cost estimation is crucial for success. One method widely used is Bottom-Up Cost Estimating, a meticulous approach that ensures detailed cost analysis and minimizes surprises during project execution.

What is Bottom-Up Cost Estimating?

Imagine a project as a giant puzzle. Bottom-up cost estimating breaks this puzzle down into its smallest pieces – individual tasks – and then assesses the cost of each piece. These individual costs are then summed up to create a comprehensive total project cost estimate.

How it Works in Oil & Gas:

Detailed Work Breakdown Structure (WBS): The project is meticulously broken down into manageable tasks, often using a hierarchical structure. This ensures that every aspect of the project is accounted for.
Task-Level Costing: Each task is thoroughly analyzed, and a detailed cost estimate is prepared. This includes labor, materials, equipment, logistics, and any other relevant expenses.
Resource Allocation: The required personnel, equipment, and materials for each task are identified, and their costs are determined based on market rates and historical data.
Summing Up: The individual task costs are then aggregated to arrive at the total project cost estimate.

Advantages of Bottom-Up Cost Estimating:

Accuracy: By focusing on individual tasks, this method provides a more accurate and detailed cost estimate compared to top-down approaches.
Transparency: The detailed breakdown allows stakeholders to clearly understand the cost drivers for each project element.
Risk Mitigation: By identifying potential cost overruns at the task level, bottom-up estimating helps mitigate risks during project execution.
Improved Budgeting: The detailed cost estimate provides a solid foundation for project budgeting and financial planning.

Challenges of Bottom-Up Cost Estimating:

Time-Consuming: This method requires significant time and effort to gather and analyze data for each individual task.
Data Intensive: Accessing accurate historical data and market information is crucial for reliable cost estimates.
Complexity: Large, complex projects with many interdependencies can make the process challenging.

Conclusion:

While requiring significant effort, Bottom-Up Cost Estimating remains a valuable tool for oil and gas companies. Its detailed analysis and meticulous approach provide a strong foundation for accurate cost estimates, facilitating informed decision-making, improved risk management, and ultimately, project success.

Test Your Knowledge

Quiz: Bottom-Up Cost Estimating in Oil & Gas

Instructions: Choose the best answer for each question.

1. Which of the following is a key characteristic of Bottom-Up Cost Estimating?

a) Estimating based on historical data from similar projects b) Breaking down the project into its smallest tasks c) Using a top-down approach to determine overall project costs d) Focusing primarily on the overall budget and less on individual tasks

Answer

b) Breaking down the project into its smallest tasks

2. What is the primary benefit of using a Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) in Bottom-Up Cost Estimating?

a) To identify potential risks b) To track project progress c) To ensure all project elements are accounted for d) To allocate resources effectively

Answer

c) To ensure all project elements are accounted for

3. Which of the following is NOT an advantage of Bottom-Up Cost Estimating?

a) Increased accuracy b) Improved communication and transparency c) Reduced project execution time d) Enhanced risk mitigation

Answer

c) Reduced project execution time

4. What is a significant challenge associated with Bottom-Up Cost Estimating?

a) Lack of available historical data b) Difficulty in identifying potential risks c) The inability to accurately predict market fluctuations d) Limited stakeholder involvement

Answer

a) Lack of available historical data

5. In the context of Oil & Gas projects, why is Bottom-Up Cost Estimating considered valuable?

a) It simplifies the budgeting process b) It promotes faster project completion c) It provides a detailed and accurate cost analysis d) It eliminates the need for top-down estimates

Answer

c) It provides a detailed and accurate cost analysis

Exercise: Applying Bottom-Up Cost Estimating

Scenario:

You are a cost estimator working on a project to construct a new offshore drilling platform. Your team has identified the following major tasks:

Platform Design & Engineering: Requires specialized engineering expertise and software.
Material Procurement: Purchasing specialized steel, concrete, and equipment.
Construction & Installation: Assembling and installing the platform offshore.
Testing & Commissioning: Ensuring the platform meets safety and operational standards.

Task:

Using the information provided, create a simple Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) for this project, breaking down each major task into at least 2 sub-tasks. Then, describe how you would estimate the cost of each sub-task using Bottom-Up Cost Estimating.

Exercice Correction

**Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)** 1. **Platform Design & Engineering** * 1.1 Detailed Design & Engineering (including software licenses) * 1.2 Regulatory Approvals & Permits 2. **Material Procurement** * 2.1 Procurement of Steel and Concrete * 2.2 Procurement of Drilling Equipment & Machinery 3. **Construction & Installation** * 3.1 Platform Assembly at Shipyard * 3.2 Offshore Transportation & Installation 4. **Testing & Commissioning** * 4.1 Pre-Commissioning Tests & Inspections * 4.2 Commissioning & Acceptance Testing **Cost Estimation using Bottom-Up Approach** * **For each sub-task:** * **Identify Required Resources:** Define the specific labor, equipment, materials, and services needed for each sub-task. * **Determine Cost of Resources:** Research market rates for labor (salaries and hourly rates), equipment rental, material prices, and service costs. * **Calculate Cost of Sub-task:** Multiply the quantity of each resource by its corresponding cost to arrive at the total cost of the sub-task. * **Consider Indirect Costs:** Account for indirect costs like project management, insurance, and overhead expenses. **Example:** * **Sub-task 1.1:** Detailed Design & Engineering * **Resources:** 5 engineers (with specific expertise) for 6 months, specialized software licenses. * **Cost of Resources:** Engineer salaries (based on market rates) for 6 months, software license fees. * **Calculate Sub-task Cost:** Multiply the total cost of engineers (salary x 6 months) by the number of engineers plus the software license cost.

Books

"Cost Engineering" by John A. Dale (This classic text covers various cost estimation techniques, including bottom-up approaches, within the context of engineering projects.)
"Project Management for Engineering and Construction" by K.R. Bhavikatti (This book offers a comprehensive overview of project management, including sections on cost estimation and bottom-up techniques.)
"Cost Estimating for Engineering and Construction" by Michael J. Battaglia (Focuses on cost estimating methodologies, including bottom-up, for various engineering and construction projects.)

Articles

"Bottom-Up Cost Estimating in the Oil & Gas Industry" by John Doe (Company Name) (This is a placeholder title - search for relevant articles in industry journals like "Oil & Gas Journal" or "SPE Journal".)
"Best Practices for Bottom-Up Cost Estimating in Oil and Gas Projects" by Jane Smith (Consulting firm) (Search for articles on cost estimating best practices for specific industries like oil & gas.)
"The Importance of Accurate Cost Estimation in the Oil & Gas Industry" by Project Management Institute (PMI) (This is a potential article title - search for articles on the impact of accurate cost estimating for the industry.)

Online Resources

Project Management Institute (PMI) - Cost Management: (PMI provides resources on cost estimation, budgeting, and control, including bottom-up approaches.) https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/cost-management
AACE International (Association for the Advancement of Cost Engineering): (AACE provides resources on cost engineering, including bottom-up cost estimating, best practices, and training.) https://www.aacei.org/
Cost Engineering: Resources and Links: (This website offers various resources and links on cost engineering, including articles and training materials.) https://www.cost-engineering.com/

Search Tips

Use specific keywords: Include terms like "bottom-up cost estimating," "oil and gas," "project management," "cost engineering," and relevant project types (e.g., upstream, downstream, LNG, etc.).
Combine keywords: Use phrases like "bottom-up cost estimating techniques in oil and gas projects" or "best practices for bottom-up cost estimation in the upstream oil and gas industry."
Filter your search: Use Google's search filters to specify the search timeframe, file type (e.g., PDF), and language to find more relevant results.
Explore industry websites: Search for articles and resources on websites of organizations like PMI, AACE International, and industry associations specific to oil and gas.