Finance internationale

Currency Fixings

L'Héritage Durable (et les Dangers Potentiels) des Fixations Monétaires sur les Marchés Financiers

Pendant des décennies, le terme « fixations monétaires » évoquait l'image d'un rituel quotidien soigneusement orchestré dans les centres financiers mondiaux. Sur certains marchés, notamment ceux dotés de régimes de taux de change moins flexibles, un processus formel – souvent impliquant une réunion quotidienne – déterminait les taux de change officiels de diverses devises. Cette « fixation » n'était pas une simple annonce ; elle impliquait un ajustement actif des niveaux d'achat et de vente des devises pour refléter les conditions du marché prévalant, souvent avec une influence significative de la banque centrale du pays. Bien que l'importance des fixations formelles ait diminué à l'ère des taux de change flottants, la compréhension de leur histoire et de leur résurgence potentielle reste cruciale pour quiconque navigue dans la finance internationale.

Fonctionnement des Fixations Monétaires (et leur Fonctionnement Actuel dans Certains Contexts) :

Traditionnellement, le processus de fixation impliquait un groupe de courtiers et de banques agréés se réunissant à une heure prédéterminée. Ils évaluaient l'offre et la demande du marché pour chaque devise, en tenant compte de facteurs tels que les flux commerciaux, les mouvements de capitaux et les politiques gouvernementales. La banque centrale jouait un rôle clé, intervenant souvent directement en achetant ou en vendant sa propre devise pour orienter la fixation vers un niveau souhaité. Cette intervention visait à atteindre divers objectifs macroéconomiques, tels que le maintien de la stabilité du taux de change, le contrôle de l'inflation ou la gestion de la balance des paiements du pays. Le taux « fixé » résultant servait alors de référence pour les transactions de la journée, impactant tout, des transactions internationales à l'évaluation des actifs libellés dans ces devises.

Exemples et Pertinence Contemporaine :

Bien que la fixation de l'or de Londres reste un exemple notable de processus de fixation quotidienne, l'adoption généralisée des taux de change flottants a considérablement réduit la dépendance aux fixations monétaires formelles. Cependant, des éléments de fixation persistent sous différentes formes :

  • Taux de change flottants gérés : De nombreux pays fonctionnent sous des régimes de taux de change flottants gérés, où la banque centrale intervient sur le marché des changes pour influencer le taux de change, mais pas par le biais d'une fixation quotidienne formelle. Ces interventions sont souvent moins transparentes et plus réactives que le processus de fixation traditionnel.
  • Conseils monétaires : Dans certains pays, un conseil monétaire fixe rigoureusement la monnaie nationale à une autre (par exemple, une parité fixe). Bien qu'il ne s'agisse pas d'une fixation quotidienne, le taux de change est effectivement fixe et maintenu grâce à une politique monétaire stricte.
  • Fixations informelles et taux de référence : Même sur les marchés flottants libres, divers taux de référence, tels que les taux WM/Reuters largement suivis, fournissent des références pour l'évaluation des devises. Ces taux, bien que non formellement « fixés », jouent toujours un rôle important dans la tarification et le règlement.

Avantages et Inconvénients des Fixations Monétaires :

Avantages :

  • Stabilité du taux de change : Les fixations peuvent apporter certitude et prévisibilité aux entreprises impliquées dans le commerce et l'investissement internationaux.
  • Contrôle de l'inflation : Un taux de change stable peut contribuer à contrôler l'inflation, notamment dans les pays dont l'économie dépend des importations.
  • Réduction du risque de change : Les taux de change fixes éliminent le risque de fluctuations monétaires soudaines.

Inconvénients :

  • Perte d'indépendance de la politique monétaire : Le maintien d'un taux de change fixe exige souvent que la banque centrale subordonne ses objectifs de politique monétaire au maintien du taux fixe.
  • Attaques spéculatives : Un taux de change fixe peut devenir vulnérable aux attaques spéculatives si les acteurs du marché estiment que la parité est insoutenable.
  • Désalignement des taux de change : Un taux de change fixe peut se désaligner des fondamentaux économiques au fil du temps, entraînant des distorsions dans l'économie.

Conclusion :

Si l'ère des fixations monétaires quotidiennes formelles est peut-être en voie de disparition, les principes sous-jacents – l'intervention des banques centrales et la nécessité d'une gestion des taux de change – restent pertinents. La compréhension du contexte historique des fixations monétaires fournit des informations précieuses sur les régimes de taux de change contemporains et les défis permanents liés au maintien de la stabilité dans un système financier mondialisé. L'avenir pourrait voir une résurgence de systèmes de taux de change gérés, nécessitant une attention renouvelée sur les avantages et les inconvénients potentiels de techniques qui, sous une forme modifiée, font écho à l'héritage de la fixation monétaire.

Test Your Knowledge

Quiz: The Enduring Legacy of Currency Fixings

Instructions: Choose the best answer for each multiple-choice question.

1. Historically, the process of currency fixing primarily involved:

a) Algorithmic calculations based on market data. b) A daily meeting of authorized dealers and banks to determine exchange rates, often with central bank influence. c) A completely free market determination of exchange rates with no central bank intervention. d) Randomly assigning exchange rates based on a lottery system.

Answer

b) A daily meeting of authorized dealers and banks to determine exchange rates, often with central bank influence.

2. Which of the following is NOT a contemporary example of a form of currency fixing or rate management?

a) Managed floats b) Currency boards c) Completely free-floating exchange rates d) Informal fixings and reference rates

Answer

c) Completely free-floating exchange rates

3. A key advantage of currency fixings is:

a) Increased volatility and unpredictability in exchange rates. b) Enhanced monetary policy independence for central banks. c) Reduced exchange rate risk for businesses engaged in international trade. d) The encouragement of speculative attacks on the currency.

Answer

c) Reduced exchange rate risk for businesses engaged in international trade.

4. A significant disadvantage of maintaining a fixed exchange rate is:

a) Increased inflation. b) The potential for misalignment of exchange rates with economic fundamentals over time. c) The promotion of free and open markets. d) Greater flexibility in responding to economic shocks.

Answer

b) The potential for misalignment of exchange rates with economic fundamentals over time.

5. The London gold fixing is an example of:

a) A modern, algorithmic approach to currency determination. b) A historical practice that is completely irrelevant to today's markets. c) A continuing example of a daily fixing process, although not for currencies. d) A system used exclusively for managing the exchange rates of developing nations.

Answer

c) A continuing example of a daily fixing process, although not for currencies.

Exercise: Analyzing a Hypothetical Scenario

Scenario: Imagine a small island nation, Isla Perdida, heavily reliant on tourism and importing most of its manufactured goods. Isla Perdida has historically maintained a fixed exchange rate with the US dollar. Recently, however, there has been a significant decrease in tourist arrivals due to a global pandemic, and a substantial increase in the price of imported goods due to global supply chain disruptions.

Task: Analyze the potential economic consequences for Isla Perdida of maintaining its fixed exchange rate under these circumstances. Discuss at least three potential consequences and suggest possible actions the Isla Perdida central bank might take. Consider the advantages and disadvantages of each action.

Exercice Correction

Maintaining the fixed exchange rate under these circumstances would likely create several economic problems for Isla Perdida:

  1. Balance of Payments Crisis: The decrease in tourism revenue (a major source of foreign currency) and the increase in the cost of imports would worsen Isla Perdida's balance of payments. The central bank would need to spend its foreign currency reserves to maintain the peg, potentially depleting these reserves to a dangerous level.
  2. Inflation: Increased import prices, coupled with reduced tourism revenue, could lead to higher inflation. Since the exchange rate is fixed, the central bank cannot use monetary policy (e.g., raising interest rates) to control inflation effectively.
  3. Economic Recession: The combined effects of reduced tourism and increased import costs would likely depress economic activity, leading to a recession. Businesses would struggle with higher input costs, and reduced demand.

Possible Actions by the Central Bank:

  1. Devaluation (abandoning the peg): This would make Isla Perdida's exports more competitive and imports less expensive (in local currency terms), potentially boosting tourism and reducing inflation. However, it also leads to higher prices for imported goods in the short term and increased uncertainty, which could hurt confidence.
  2. Implementing Capital Controls: Restricting the outflow of capital could help conserve foreign exchange reserves, but this would hurt investment and might discourage tourism. It could also be seen as a sign of economic instability which further discourages investment.
  3. Seeking International Assistance: Isla Perdida could seek financial assistance from international organizations (like the IMF) to help shore up its foreign currency reserves and implement necessary economic reforms. This might involve implementing austerity measures, potentially worsening the economic situation in the short term but offering longer-term stability.

The best course of action would depend on Isla Perdida's specific circumstances and the severity of the economic crisis, along with its political will to potentially accept short-term pain for longer-term gain. There's no easy solution, and each option carries both benefits and significant drawbacks.

Books

  • *
  • International Finance: Many textbooks on international finance will cover currency regimes, including fixed exchange rates. Search for books with titles including "International Finance," "International Monetary Economics," or "Exchange Rate Economics." Look for chapters or sections specifically on exchange rate regimes, currency boards, and central bank intervention. Authors like Mishkin, Obstfeld & Rogoff, and Frankel are good starting points.
  • History of Central Banking: Books focusing on the history of central banking in specific countries or globally will often detail the use of currency fixings and their impact. Look for books focusing on periods where fixed exchange rates were prevalent (e.g., Bretton Woods era).
  • Financial History: General books on financial history will provide context for the evolution of currency markets and the role of fixings.
  • II. Articles (Academic Journals):*
  • Journal of International Economics: Search this journal for articles on exchange rate regimes, currency crises, and central bank intervention. Keywords: "fixed exchange rates," "currency pegs," "central bank intervention," "speculative attacks," "exchange rate crises."
  • Journal of Monetary Economics: Similar to the above, this journal publishes research on monetary policy and its impact on exchange rates.
  • IMF Working Papers: The International Monetary Fund publishes numerous working papers on exchange rate issues. Their website is a valuable resource. Search for keywords related to currency boards, exchange rate regimes, and emerging market exchange rate policies.
  • Economic Journal: Search for articles related to exchange rate determination and the history of different currency systems.
  • *III.

Articles

    • Use advanced search operators like "filetype:pdf" to find PDF documents or specify search engines like Google Scholar to focus on academic publications. By using these resources and search strategies, you can delve deeper into the historical context, contemporary relevance, and potential future implications of currency fixings in the global financial system. Remember to critically evaluate the sources and consider the perspectives of different authors and institutions.


Online Resources

  • *
  • International Monetary Fund (IMF): The IMF website (imf.org) offers data, publications, and research on exchange rates and monetary policy across countries. Their publications database is particularly useful.
  • Bank for International Settlements (BIS): The BIS (bis.org) is another excellent source of information on international monetary and financial matters. They publish working papers and reports on various aspects of the global financial system, including exchange rate regimes.
  • World Bank: The World Bank website (worldbank.org) provides data and reports on global economic indicators, including exchange rates and macroeconomic variables.
  • Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED): FRED (fred.stlouisfed.org) is a comprehensive database maintained by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. It offers historical data on various economic indicators, including exchange rates.
  • *IV. Google

Search Tips

  • * Use precise keywords in your Google searches for better results:- General: "currency fixing history," "Bretton Woods exchange rate system," "currency board mechanisms," "managed floating exchange rates," "central bank intervention foreign exchange market," "speculative attacks fixed exchange rates," "exchange rate crises pegged currencies"
  • Specific Countries/Regions: Add a country or region to your searches (e.g., "currency fixing Hong Kong," "currency board Argentina").
  • Specific Time Periods: Refine your searches by specifying a time period (e.g., "currency fixings 1970s," "currency fixings post-Bretton Woods").
  • **Scholarly

Techniques

The Enduring Legacy (and Potential Perils) of Currency Fixings in Financial Markets

Chapter 1: Techniques

The mechanics of currency fixings varied depending on the specific context and the degree of central bank intervention. Historically, the process often involved a formal meeting of authorized dealers and banks at a predetermined time. These participants, representing major financial institutions, would assess the prevailing market conditions, considering:

  • Supply and Demand: The balance between buyers and sellers of a particular currency played a crucial role. High demand for a currency would push its value up, while excess supply would have the opposite effect.

  • Trade Flows: The volume of imports and exports significantly influenced currency demand. A country with a large trade surplus (exporting more than it imports) would typically see its currency appreciate.

  • Capital Flows: Movements of capital—investment into and out of a country—also influenced currency values. Large inflows of foreign investment typically strengthen a currency.

  • Government Policies: Monetary and fiscal policies implemented by the government could directly or indirectly affect exchange rates. Interest rate adjustments, for example, often impact currency values.

The central bank's role was pivotal. Its intervention, through the buying or selling of its own currency in the foreign exchange market, aimed to steer the fixing towards a desired level. This could involve:

  • Direct Intervention: The central bank directly participates in the market, buying its currency to support its value or selling it to allow depreciation.

  • Indirect Intervention: The central bank might influence market conditions through other tools, like changing interest rates or reserve requirements, indirectly affecting currency supply and demand.

The "fixed" rate resulting from this process served as a benchmark for the day's trading, influencing the valuation of assets and international transactions. The degree of flexibility within the fixing process varied, ranging from rigidly fixed exchange rates to those with a small allowed band of fluctuation.

Chapter 2: Models

Several theoretical models attempt to explain the dynamics of currency fixings and their impact on macroeconomic variables. These models often incorporate elements of:

  • Purchasing Power Parity (PPP): This theory suggests that exchange rates should adjust to equalize the purchasing power of different currencies. In a fixed exchange rate regime, deviations from PPP can lead to distortions in relative prices.

  • Interest Rate Parity (IRP): This theory relates the interest rate differential between two countries to the expected exchange rate movement. In a fixed regime, the interest rate differential should reflect the expected inflation differential.

  • Balance of Payments (BOP): A country's BOP, reflecting the flow of goods, services, and capital, influences its exchange rate. A persistent BOP deficit under a fixed regime can strain the ability to maintain the fixed rate.

Modeling currency fixings also involves considering factors like:

  • Speculative Attacks: Models need to account for the possibility of speculative attacks, where market participants bet against the sustainability of a fixed exchange rate, potentially leading to its collapse.

  • Central Bank Credibility: The credibility of the central bank in its commitment to maintain the fixed exchange rate is critical. Loss of credibility can make the fixed regime vulnerable.

  • Capital Controls: Governments sometimes impose capital controls to limit capital flows and protect the fixed exchange rate. However, these controls can distort markets and have unintended consequences. These models are complex and rely on several assumptions, often making it challenging to predict real-world outcomes accurately.

Chapter 3: Software

Software plays a vital role in both the historical practice and modern analysis of currency fixings. While the historical fixing processes were largely manual, modern tools are essential for analyzing data and modeling currency dynamics. Relevant software categories include:

  • Financial Data Providers: Bloomberg Terminal, Refinitiv Eikon, and FactSet provide real-time and historical currency exchange rate data, essential for tracking fixings and understanding market behavior. These systems also allow sophisticated data analysis and visualization.

  • Statistical Software Packages: R, Stata, and EViews are commonly used for statistical modeling of exchange rate data, allowing for econometric analysis to test various theoretical models and examine the impact of fixing mechanisms.

  • Spreadsheet Software: Microsoft Excel or Google Sheets, while less sophisticated than dedicated statistical packages, are still valuable tools for organizing and visualizing currency data, particularly for simpler analyses.

  • Trading Platforms: Professional trading platforms provide tools for executing trades based on fixing announcements or reference rates, offering real-time market data and execution capabilities.

Chapter 4: Best Practices

Effective management of currency fixings, whether through formal mechanisms or managed floats, requires careful consideration of several best practices:

  • Transparency and Predictability: Clear communication of the fixing process and the central bank's objectives are vital for market stability and to avoid speculative attacks.

  • Flexibility and Adaptability: Rigid adherence to a fixed exchange rate can be problematic. The ability to adjust the regime or intervene strategically in response to changing economic conditions is essential.

  • Strong Institutional Framework: A strong and independent central bank with well-defined mandates is crucial for effective management.

  • Sound Macroeconomic Policies: Maintaining a stable exchange rate requires a consistent and prudent macroeconomic policy framework that addresses inflation, fiscal deficits, and other economic imbalances.

  • International Cooperation: In a globalized world, cooperation with other countries and international organizations can be beneficial for managing exchange rates, particularly for countries with close economic ties.

Chapter 5: Case Studies

Several historical and contemporary examples illustrate the use and consequences of currency fixings:

  • The Bretton Woods System (1944-1971): This post-World War II system pegged currencies to the US dollar, which was, in turn, convertible to gold. While providing stability initially, it eventually collapsed under pressure from persistent US balance of payments deficits.

  • The European Monetary System (EMS): The EMS involved a system of fixed exchange rates among European currencies, paving the way for the Euro. The system faced several speculative attacks and realignments before the introduction of the single currency.

  • The Hong Kong Dollar Peg: Hong Kong maintains a currency board system, rigidly pegging its currency to the US dollar. This has provided considerable exchange rate stability but has required the monetary authority to adjust interest rates significantly in line with US policy.

  • Argentina's Peso Peg (1991-2002): Argentina's attempt to peg its currency to the US dollar ended in a severe financial crisis and currency devaluation, illustrating the risks of an unsustainable fixed exchange rate regime. These case studies showcase both the potential benefits and pitfalls of currency fixings, highlighting the complexities of exchange rate management in a dynamic global economy.

Termes similaires
Marchés financiersFinance internationale
Les plus regardés
Categories

Comments

No Comments
POST COMMENT
captcha
Back