Cost Estimation & Control

Variance

Understanding Variance in Cost Estimation & Control

In the realm of project management and financial planning, cost estimation and control are crucial for ensuring successful project execution. A key tool used in this process is variance analysis, which helps identify deviations from the planned budget and provides valuable insights for corrective actions. At the heart of this analysis lies the concept of variance, which we will explore in detail below.

Defining Variance

In simple terms, variance represents the difference between the actual or estimated cost of a project or a particular work scope and the authorized appropriation allocated for it. This difference can be either positive or negative, representing an over-run or under-run, respectively.

  • Over-run: This occurs when the actual cost exceeds the authorized appropriation, indicating that the project is costing more than anticipated.
  • Under-run: This occurs when the actual cost falls below the authorized appropriation, meaning the project is coming in under budget.

Understanding the Significance of Variance

Variance analysis is not just about identifying the difference between planned and actual costs. It provides valuable insights into the reasons behind these differences and helps in understanding the underlying factors contributing to cost deviations.

Examples of Variance:

  • Materials: If the actual cost of materials used in a construction project is higher than the estimated cost, there's a material cost variance. This could be due to price fluctuations, unexpected material requirements, or inefficiencies in procurement.
  • Labor: If the actual labor cost exceeds the estimated cost, there's a labor cost variance. This could be due to higher-than-anticipated labor rates, overtime hours, or increased workforce requirements.
  • Project Delays: Delays in project execution can lead to cost overruns due to extended timelines, additional labor costs, or increased overhead expenses.

Analyzing Variance for Effective Control

Once variances are identified, it is crucial to analyze them thoroughly. This involves:

  • Identifying the root cause: Pinpointing the reasons behind the variances helps in developing effective solutions.
  • Assessing the impact: Understanding the magnitude and potential consequences of the variances is essential for prioritizing corrective actions.
  • Developing corrective measures: Based on the analysis, appropriate steps can be taken to mitigate the impact of variances and bring costs back on track.

The Role of Variance in Cost Control

Variance analysis plays a pivotal role in cost control by:

  • Early Detection: Identifying variances early on allows for timely intervention and prevents further escalation of cost deviations.
  • Decision-Making: Variance analysis provides valuable data for informed decision-making regarding project scope, resource allocation, and budget adjustments.
  • Continuous Improvement: Regular analysis helps identify areas for improvement in cost estimation, planning, and project execution processes.

Conclusion

Variance analysis is a fundamental tool for effective cost estimation and control. By understanding the concept of variance, analyzing its root causes, and implementing corrective measures, project managers can ensure that projects are completed within the allocated budget and achieve successful financial outcomes. Continuous monitoring and analysis of variances are crucial for maintaining a proactive approach to cost management and achieving project goals efficiently.


Test Your Knowledge

Quiz: Understanding Variance in Cost Estimation & Control

Instructions: Choose the best answer for each question.

1. What does "variance" represent in the context of cost estimation and control?

a) The difference between the actual cost and the estimated cost. b) The total cost of a project. c) The budget allocated for a project. d) The profit margin on a project.

Answer

a) The difference between the actual cost and the estimated cost.

2. When does an "over-run" occur?

a) When the actual cost is lower than the estimated cost. b) When the actual cost is higher than the estimated cost. c) When the project is completed on time. d) When the project is within budget.

Answer

b) When the actual cost is higher than the estimated cost.

3. Why is variance analysis important for cost control?

a) It helps identify potential cost overruns. b) It allows for informed decision-making regarding budget adjustments. c) It helps improve cost estimation and planning processes. d) All of the above.

Answer

d) All of the above.

4. Which of the following is NOT a key step in analyzing variance?

a) Identifying the root cause of the variance. b) Assessing the impact of the variance. c) Implementing corrective measures. d) Approving the final project budget.

Answer

d) Approving the final project budget.

5. How does variance analysis contribute to continuous improvement?

a) By identifying areas for improvement in cost estimation, planning, and project execution. b) By ensuring that all projects are completed on time. c) By reducing the need for budget adjustments. d) By eliminating all potential cost overruns.

Answer

a) By identifying areas for improvement in cost estimation, planning, and project execution.

Exercise: Analyzing Variance in a Project

Scenario: You are managing a software development project with an estimated budget of $100,000. The following table shows the actual costs incurred for each project phase:

| Phase | Estimated Cost | Actual Cost | |---|---|---| | Design | $20,000 | $25,000 | | Development | $50,000 | $45,000 | | Testing | $15,000 | $18,000 | | Deployment | $15,000 | $17,000 |

Task:

  1. Calculate the variance for each phase of the project.
  2. Identify which phases have an over-run and which have an under-run.
  3. Briefly explain the potential reasons for the variance in the Design phase.
  4. Suggest two possible corrective measures to address the variance in the Testing phase.

Exercice Correction

1. Variance Calculation: * Design: $25,000 (Actual) - $20,000 (Estimated) = $5,000 Over-run * Development: $45,000 (Actual) - $50,000 (Estimated) = -$5,000 Under-run * Testing: $18,000 (Actual) - $15,000 (Estimated) = $3,000 Over-run * Deployment: $17,000 (Actual) - $15,000 (Estimated) = $2,000 Over-run 2. Over-run/Under-run: * Over-run: Design, Testing, Deployment * Under-run: Development 3. Potential Reasons for Design Phase Variance: * **Scope Creep:** The project scope might have expanded beyond the initial estimates, requiring additional design work. * **Unforeseen Complexity:** The design might have proven more complex than anticipated, necessitating more resources. * **Increased Material Costs:** The cost of design tools or software licenses might have increased. 4. Corrective Measures for Testing Phase Variance: * **Optimize Testing Process:** Review and streamline the testing process to identify inefficiencies and reduce the overall time spent on testing. * **Negotiate Lower Rates:** Explore the possibility of negotiating lower rates with external testing resources or contractors.


Books

  • Project Management Institute (PMI). (2021). A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK® Guide) - Seventh Edition. Project Management Institute. - This comprehensive guide covers various aspects of project management, including cost estimation and control. Chapter 11 specifically focuses on cost management and includes sections on variance analysis.
  • Kerzner, H. (2017). Project Management: A Systems Approach to Planning, Scheduling, and Controlling. John Wiley & Sons. - This book delves into various project management methodologies, with a dedicated section on cost management, including variance analysis and its application in project control.
  • Meredith, J. R., & Mantel, S. J. (2019). Project Management: A Managerial Approach. John Wiley & Sons. - This book provides a practical approach to project management and discusses cost management techniques, including variance analysis, within the context of project control.

Articles

  • "Variance Analysis: A Powerful Tool for Cost Control" - Project Management Institute website - This article offers a comprehensive overview of variance analysis, its significance in project management, and provides practical examples to illustrate its application.
  • "Cost Variance Analysis: The Key to Project Success" - Construction Executive - This article specifically focuses on the importance of variance analysis in construction projects, highlighting its role in identifying and mitigating cost overruns.
  • "Understanding and Using Cost Variance Analysis" - Cost Engineering - This article explores the theoretical underpinnings of variance analysis and its application in various cost management scenarios.

Online Resources

  • Project Management Institute (PMI) - Cost Management Knowledge Area - This resource provides a wealth of information on cost management, including variance analysis, within the context of project management.
  • The Standish Group - CHAOS Report - This report provides insights into project success and failure rates, highlighting the importance of cost management and variance analysis in project success.
  • Cost Engineering Council - Resources - The CEC website offers valuable resources on cost engineering, including articles and case studies related to variance analysis and cost control.

Search Tips

  • "Variance Analysis in Project Management" - This search will return articles, websites, and resources focused on the application of variance analysis in project management.
  • "Cost Variance Calculation Examples" - This search will provide examples of how to calculate cost variances and interpret the results.
  • "Variance Analysis Software" - This search will help you find software tools that can automate variance analysis and provide insights into cost deviations.

Techniques

Similar Terms
Cost Estimation & Control
Project Planning & Scheduling
Most Viewed

Comments

No Comments
POST COMMENT
captcha
Back