Preliminary Economic Criteria

Preliminary Economic Criteria: The Gatekeeper of Project Approval

In the world of cost estimation and control, the concept of Preliminary Economic Criteria (PEC) acts as a crucial gatekeeper, ensuring that projects are financially viable before significant resources are committed. It involves establishing a set of economic conditions that must be met before a project, especially one among several alternatives, can be approved.

The Importance of PEC:

PEC serves as a vital tool for:

Early Stage Decision-Making: By setting economic benchmarks upfront, PEC allows for informed decisions regarding project viability during the initial stages. This prevents investing time and resources in projects that are unlikely to generate a return.
Resource Allocation: PEC helps prioritize projects based on their economic potential. This ensures that limited resources are allocated to projects with the highest likelihood of success.
Risk Mitigation: By evaluating potential economic risks early on, PEC helps to identify and mitigate potential threats to project success.
Strategic Alignment: PEC ensures that projects align with the overall economic objectives and goals of the organization.

Key Elements of PEC:

The specific elements included in PEC will vary depending on the nature of the project and the industry. However, some common elements include:

Return on Investment (ROI): The expected return on the investment in the project, typically expressed as a percentage.
Net Present Value (NPV): The present value of the project's future cash flows, taking into account the time value of money.
Internal Rate of Return (IRR): The discount rate that makes the NPV of the project equal to zero.
Payback Period: The time it takes for the project to generate enough cash flow to recover the initial investment.
Cost-Benefit Analysis: A systematic evaluation of the project's potential benefits and costs.
Sensitivity Analysis: Assessing the impact of changes in key economic assumptions on the project's financial performance.

The Approval Process:

Once the preliminary economic criteria are defined, they are applied to each project alternative. If a project meets the established criteria, it can move forward to the next stage of development. If it does not, the project may be rejected or revised to improve its economic viability.

Beyond the Numbers:

While PEC primarily focuses on financial metrics, it's important to consider other factors that contribute to a project's success. These include:

Market Demand: The level of demand for the goods or services produced by the project.
Competitive Landscape: The presence and strength of competitors in the market.
Technological Feasibility: The availability and cost of the technology required for the project.
Regulatory Environment: The impact of government regulations on the project's feasibility.

In Conclusion:

Preliminary Economic Criteria is a vital tool for making informed decisions about project investments. By establishing clear economic benchmarks early in the project development cycle, organizations can ensure that they are allocating resources to projects with the highest likelihood of success and aligning their projects with their overall economic objectives. It is a critical step in ensuring that projects are not only feasible but also deliver the desired economic returns.

Test Your Knowledge

Quiz: Preliminary Economic Criteria

Instructions: Choose the best answer for each question.

1. What is the primary purpose of Preliminary Economic Criteria (PEC)? a) To determine the project's budget. b) To evaluate the project's financial viability. c) To select the project manager. d) To define the project scope.

Answer

b) To evaluate the project's financial viability.

2. Which of the following is NOT a common element of PEC? a) Return on Investment (ROI) b) Net Present Value (NPV) c) Project Charter d) Payback Period

Answer

c) Project Charter

3. What does Sensitivity Analysis aim to assess in the context of PEC? a) The impact of changes in project scope on budget. b) The impact of changes in team members on project timeline. c) The impact of changes in key economic assumptions on financial performance. d) The impact of changes in regulatory environment on project feasibility.

Answer

c) The impact of changes in key economic assumptions on financial performance.

4. What happens to a project if it does NOT meet the established PEC? a) The project is automatically approved. b) The project is immediately canceled. c) The project may be rejected or revised to improve its economic viability. d) The project is put on hold indefinitely.

Answer

c) The project may be rejected or revised to improve its economic viability.

5. Beyond financial metrics, which of the following is considered crucial for a project's success? a) Project team morale b) Market demand c) Availability of office space d) Number of stakeholders involved

Answer

b) Market demand

Exercise:

Imagine you are evaluating two project proposals for a new software product. Both projects aim to address the same market need but have different development approaches and estimated costs. Use the following information to apply PEC and determine which project is more economically viable:

Project A:

Initial Investment: $1 million
Estimated Annual Revenue: $500,000
Estimated Annual Operating Costs: $200,000
Project Life: 5 years

Project B:

Initial Investment: $500,000
Estimated Annual Revenue: $300,000
Estimated Annual Operating Costs: $100,000
Project Life: 5 years

Calculate the following for each project:

Return on Investment (ROI)
Net Present Value (NPV) (Assume a discount rate of 10%)
Payback Period

Based on your calculations, which project would you recommend and why?

Exercice Correction

Here's a breakdown of the calculations and the recommended project:

Project A:

ROI: [(Total Revenue - Total Costs) / Initial Investment] * 100
ROI = [($500,000 * 5) - ($200,000 * 5) - $1,000,000] / $1,000,000 * 100
ROI = 150%
NPV: (Present Value of Future Cash Flows - Initial Investment)
NPV = [(($500,000 - $200,000) / (1 + 0.1)^1) + (($500,000 - $200,000) / (1 + 0.1)^2) + ... + (($500,000 - $200,000) / (1 + 0.1)^5)] - $1,000,000
NPV = $936,590
Payback Period: Initial Investment / Annual Net Cash Flow
Payback Period = $1,000,000 / ($500,000 - $200,000)
Payback Period = 3.33 years

Project B:

ROI: [(Total Revenue - Total Costs) / Initial Investment] * 100
ROI = [($300,000 * 5) - ($100,000 * 5) - $500,000] / $500,000 * 100
ROI = 200%
NPV: (Present Value of Future Cash Flows - Initial Investment)
NPV = [(($300,000 - $100,000) / (1 + 0.1)^1) + (($300,000 - $100,000) / (1 + 0.1)^2) + ... + (($300,000 - $100,000) / (1 + 0.1)^5)] - $500,000
NPV = $576,130
Payback Period: Initial Investment / Annual Net Cash Flow
Payback Period = $500,000 / ($300,000 - $100,000)
Payback Period = 2.5 years

Recommendation:

Based on the calculated metrics, Project B is more economically viable. While Project A has a higher NPV, Project B boasts a higher ROI and a significantly shorter payback period. This means that Project B will generate a higher return on the initial investment and recoup its costs faster.

Remember, this is a simplified analysis. Other factors like market demand, competitive landscape, and technological feasibility should be considered alongside PEC to make a comprehensive project evaluation.

Books

Engineering Economy by Leland Blank and Anthony Tarquin: This classic textbook covers the fundamentals of economic analysis for engineering projects, including the concept of preliminary economic criteria.
Project Management: A Systems Approach to Planning, Scheduling, and Controlling by Harold Kerzner: This comprehensive guide to project management includes sections on project selection and evaluation, where preliminary economic criteria are discussed.
Cost Engineering by John A. Murphy: This book focuses on the principles and practices of cost estimation and control, with a dedicated chapter on project feasibility analysis that includes the use of preliminary economic criteria.

Articles

"Preliminary Economic Evaluation of Projects" by the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE): This article provides a detailed explanation of the process and importance of preliminary economic analysis in civil engineering projects.
"The Role of Preliminary Economic Analysis in Project Selection" by the Project Management Institute (PMI): This article discusses the significance of preliminary economic criteria in the context of project selection and resource allocation.
"Economic Feasibility Analysis: A Guide for Project Managers" by ProjectManagement.com: This article offers a practical guide to conducting economic feasibility analysis, covering key metrics and considerations for preliminary economic criteria.

Online Resources

Project Management Institute (PMI): The PMI website features a vast library of resources, including articles, webinars, and case studies on project management, with relevant content on economic evaluation and preliminary criteria.
American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE): ASCE offers a wealth of information on civil engineering projects, including best practices for conducting preliminary economic evaluations.
Engineering Economics Tutorials: Several online platforms provide free tutorials on engineering economy and project evaluation, covering various aspects of preliminary economic criteria.

Search Tips

Use specific keywords: Include terms like "Preliminary Economic Criteria," "Project Feasibility Analysis," "Economic Evaluation," and "Return on Investment" in your searches.
Combine keywords with industry-specific terms: Refine your search by adding terms related to your field, such as "pharmaceutical," "construction," or "software development."
Explore advanced search operators: Utilize operators like "site:" to limit your search to specific websites, and "filetype:" to find documents in specific formats (e.g., PDF).