Design to Cost

Design to Cost: Optimizing Oil & Gas Projects for Success

In the competitive and ever-evolving landscape of the Oil & Gas industry, achieving profitability requires a delicate balance between innovation and cost-efficiency. Design to Cost (DTC) emerges as a critical tool to navigate this challenge, enabling companies to deliver high-quality projects within strict budget constraints.

What is Design to Cost?

Design to Cost is a proactive approach that integrates cost considerations into every stage of the design process. It's not about sacrificing quality or functionality, but rather about optimizing the design to achieve the best value for the given budget. This involves:

Predetermined Cost Goals: Setting clear and realistic cost targets upfront, based on market analysis, competitor benchmarks, and project requirements.
Value Engineering: Analyzing every component and system to identify cost-saving opportunities without compromising performance or safety. This can involve exploring alternative materials, simplifying designs, or optimizing fabrication processes.
Collaboration and Communication: Open dialogue between engineers, procurement teams, and management throughout the design process, ensuring everyone is aligned on cost objectives.
Continuous Monitoring: Tracking costs against the predetermined goals, identifying potential overruns early, and implementing corrective measures.

Benefits of Design to Cost in Oil & Gas:

Cost Control: DTC helps prevent costly overruns and ensures projects are delivered within budget.
Increased Profitability: By optimizing costs, DTC improves project margins and enhances overall profitability.
Faster Time to Market: Streamlined designs and efficient procurement processes lead to quicker project completion and faster returns on investment.
Improved Project Success: By addressing cost concerns early on, DTC reduces the risk of project delays or cancellations.
Enhanced Innovation: DTC encourages creative solutions and drives innovation by focusing on value-driven design.

Key Considerations for Implementing DTC:

Clear Project Objectives: Clearly define the project's purpose, functionality, and performance requirements to guide design decisions.
Early Cost Estimation: Conduct detailed cost estimates during the initial phases to establish realistic cost targets.
Involve Experts: Engage experienced cost engineers and value analysts to provide guidance and expertise throughout the design process.
Flexibility and Adaptability: Be prepared to adjust the design as new information emerges and costs fluctuate.
Open Communication: Foster open communication and collaboration across all stakeholders to ensure everyone is aligned on cost goals.

Design to Cost is not a one-size-fits-all solution. The specific approach and implementation will vary depending on the nature of the project, its complexity, and the overall project lifecycle. However, its core principle of integrating cost considerations into every step of the design process offers a powerful framework for optimizing oil and gas projects for success.

By embracing DTC, oil and gas companies can unlock significant cost savings, improve profitability, and ultimately deliver projects that meet both business and operational needs.

Test Your Knowledge

Design to Cost Quiz:

Instructions: Choose the best answer for each question.

1. What is the primary goal of Design to Cost (DTC)? a) To reduce the quality of a project to meet a budget. b) To optimize the design for the best value within a defined budget. c) To create a design that is as cheap as possible, regardless of quality. d) To eliminate all costs from a project.

Answer

b) To optimize the design for the best value within a defined budget.

2. Which of the following is NOT a key element of Design to Cost? a) Predetermined Cost Goals b) Value Engineering c) Project Delays d) Collaboration and Communication

Answer

c) Project Delays

3. What is the main benefit of involving cost engineers and value analysts in the design process? a) They can provide expertise in cost estimation and value optimization. b) They can create delays in the project by overanalyzing costs. c) They can ensure the project will be completed within the budget. d) They can make all the design decisions.

Answer

a) They can provide expertise in cost estimation and value optimization.

4. How does Design to Cost contribute to faster time to market? a) By reducing the quality of the project, it speeds up the construction phase. b) By optimizing designs and procurement processes, it reduces project completion time. c) By delaying decisions, it allows for more time to analyze costs. d) By focusing on innovation, it reduces the time it takes to develop new technologies.

Answer

b) By optimizing designs and procurement processes, it reduces project completion time.

5. Which of the following statements is TRUE about Design to Cost? a) It is a one-size-fits-all solution for all oil and gas projects. b) It requires sacrificing quality and functionality to achieve cost savings. c) It encourages a culture of innovation by focusing on value-driven design. d) It is a reactive approach that addresses cost issues only after they arise.

Answer

c) It encourages a culture of innovation by focusing on value-driven design.

Design to Cost Exercise:

Scenario: You are a project manager responsible for designing a new offshore oil drilling platform. The budget for the project is $100 million.

Task: Identify three potential cost-saving opportunities using Design to Cost principles. Briefly explain how each opportunity could be implemented.

Exercice Correction

Here are three potential cost-saving opportunities, with explanations:

Material Optimization:
- Opportunity: Explore using alternative, more cost-effective materials for non-critical components of the platform. For example, using high-strength steel instead of more expensive alloys for some structural elements.
- Implementation: Conduct a thorough analysis of material properties and cost-benefit ratios. Collaborate with engineers and procurement teams to select the most suitable and cost-effective materials for each component.
Simplified Design:
- Opportunity: Streamline the design of the drilling platform by removing unnecessary features and complexity. For example, reducing the number of decks or simplifying the drilling equipment layout.
- Implementation: Conduct a value engineering analysis to identify features that can be simplified or eliminated without compromising functionality. Use 3D modeling tools to visualize and optimize the design for efficiency.
Modular Construction:
- Opportunity: Break down the platform construction into modular sections that can be fabricated separately and assembled at the offshore site. This can reduce construction time and costs.
- Implementation: Collaborate with fabrication and construction companies to define the modular sections and develop standardized designs. This allows for prefabrication in controlled environments, reducing on-site construction costs and risks.

Books

Value Engineering: A Practical Guide to Cost Reduction by Miles G. Roman (Provides a comprehensive overview of value engineering principles applicable to DTC).
Design to Cost: The Complete Guide to Achieving Profitability through Cost-Effective Design by Richard W. Swenson (Focuses on the application of DTC across different industries, with examples relevant to Oil & Gas).
Project Management for Oil and Gas: A Practical Guide to Success by Michael R. LeMay (Discusses cost management as a critical aspect of Oil & Gas project management, which aligns with DTC principles).

Articles

"Design to Cost: Optimizing Oil & Gas Projects for Success" by [Author's Name] (The provided article itself can be considered a relevant reference).
"Design to Cost in Oil and Gas: A Guide to Achieving Project Success" by [Author's Name] (Search for articles with similar titles on platforms like SPE, Oil & Gas Journal, and other industry publications).
"Value Engineering for Cost Reduction in Oil & Gas Projects" by [Author's Name] (Explore articles discussing the intersection of value engineering and cost reduction strategies in the Oil & Gas sector).

Online Resources

Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE): Their website (https://www.spe.org/) offers numerous resources, publications, and events related to oil and gas project management, including cost management techniques.
Oil & Gas Journal: This publication (https://www.ogj.com/) provides industry news, technical articles, and analyses, including articles focused on cost optimization and DTC in Oil & Gas.
American Society of Engineering Education (ASEE): Their website (https://www.asee.org/) includes resources on engineering design and cost management principles applicable to various industries, including Oil & Gas.
Cost Engineering Council: This organization (https://www.costengineeringcouncil.org/) provides information on cost engineering best practices and certifications relevant to DTC implementation.

Search Tips

Use specific keywords: Combine terms like "Design to Cost," "Oil & Gas," "Project Management," "Cost Optimization," and "Value Engineering" to narrow down your search results.
Specify publication types: Include "pdf" or "articles" in your search query to filter results to relevant documents.
Use Boolean operators: Employ "AND," "OR," and "NOT" to refine your search based on specific criteria. For example, "Design to Cost AND Oil & Gas NOT software."
Explore related keywords: Utilize Google's "Related Searches" feature at the bottom of the search results page to discover other relevant terms and concepts.